Back to Squawk list
  • 57

Engine Out Caught On Video, Well Performed

제출됨
 
A 22-year-old instructor suffered an engine out while flying with his 18-year-old student in a Jabiru J-170 at Victoria Point, Australia, two weeks ago and all ended ruggedly, but well, for the pair in a sequence that was captured by an in-cockpit video recorder (www.avweb.com) 기타...

Sort type: [Top] [Newest]


randomguy
randomguy 20
If I were the student, I'd think I just found a guy I'd take lessons from again.
rockie5112
It must be a horrible thing to go through life thinking every thing is "staged" or a conspiracy. This Kid did a great job and deserves all the credit he is getting.Chalet, go back to flying your google sim.
briancrosby
So we have determined two things....

1. The pilot did an amazing job
2. Chalet is a jackass
chalet
chalet -7
And what are you
HunterTS4
I have a sense of humor.
HunterTS4
Toby Sharp -2
Chalet is a great guy.....somebody just burned his breakfast this mornin' is all. Knock it off. let's go home.
chalet
chalet 1
How did you know it, did the CIA or FBI tell you that, LIMAO
joelwiley
Blame Snowden, it was the No Such Agency
:)
chalet
chalet 2
He is frozen in London now, it can't be him
chalet
chalet 1
Blame Bush (LIMAO)
David7700
At 1100' (the article doesn't say if this is AGL or ASL) I don't think you'd be leaning at all. I keep mixture full rich at pattern altitude at KFCI at 1200' ASL. Doing simulated engine outs at 1200' when I know where the runway is and where I am going to go, I have a quick second or two to simulate checking the mixture, switching tanks, turning on the fuel pump, ignition, etc. Looks like he used that time to find a suitable place to set the plane down.

When the engine quits (they are saying it was surging before that, so the CFI had taken over from the first time student), the CFI reaches for the mixture. It is between the seats behind the yoke. I assume he is checking full rich, but there's a choke and carb heat on the panel there, too. There might be trim there as well, I can't tell from the cockpit pictures I googled.

It then appears to me he is looking for a place to land. He keeps touching the throttle and the mixture/carb heat/choke/trim, but I do not see him touch the ignition. It looks like he continues focusing on finding a landing spot that he can make.

At that altitude, he probably decided not to try a restart (or never had much time to think about that). I won't second guess that.

When he turns final for his field and knows he has it made, he puts in the flaps. It looks like he lines up for the field behind the pond, but doesn't like something he sees, so he sidesteps across that pump house. The prop struck a fence on landing and broke. It looks like he pulled the mixture back as they rolled to a stop.

I think he did a great job.
onceastudentpilot
I didn't have any audio....but I noticed the mixture never moved and he never tried to restart it......could be staged but I doubt it.....not enriching the the mixture would cause the engine to stop too.
jackaus
jackaus 1
This Jabiru aircraft has no mixture control.
rxcw43
rxcw43 1
I agree. The PF also continues to have his right hand on the throttle seeming to adjust it throughout the video. At the time the engine "stopped" there was almost no reaction by either person that such a thing happened. And to echo your point, he never tried to restart nor did he make any adjustments to the engine controls at the time the prop appeared to stop turning.
Skeptical...
David7700
I think he was looking for a place to land. I keep my hand on the throttle instinctively anytime I am at pattern altitude or below. Our FAA likes that, and my CFI would pull the power if my hand strayed from it unless we were too low like on take off--then he would just elbow me until I put my hand back.
colinpayette
My first impression was that they'd already gone through the checklist and were having engine trouble before the propellor stopped windmilling, before the start of this video.
Steamjet
Steamjet 2
NICE JOB..... A real pro....
HunterTS4
I'd create a Flight Instructor page advertising myself and put that on there.
bovineone
There is a little more detail at the original story from the Australian news source's article: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-03/pilot-makes-emergency-landing-in-light-aircraft/4931182
David7700
Plus here are some other pictures of the plane, one showing the broken prop:

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/plane-makes-emergency-landing-in-victoria-point-paddock-20130820-2s8em.html
JHunt21
I guess some of your expertise isn't from first hand experience. When I had an engine failure I was extremely calm and reverted to my previous training and instinct. I was in a mooney when the engine stopped and I was a little higher then he was but I made sure my passengers knew what to do. I calmly told center what I was going to do. Freaking out only lets the airplane do what it wants to do and not the other way around. Remember... Calm, cool and collected! A true professional.
David7700
I've never had a true engine out. I am glad you consider yourself a professional though. Good job on how you handled your engine out.

What exactly did you take issue with in my post?
David7700
Ooops. Maybe you were not responding to my post. I never have posted here before, and I got an email that you had replied to my post (I thought), but perhaps not. Anyway, cheers.
JHunt21
Wasn't replying to you just the ones calling it fake. I do consider myself a professional but I was calling the instructor a true professional
David7700
My apologies. Just figuring out how all of this "squawking" works.
n7523y
Is that a real aircraft? It looks like a hang glider with a canopy over it.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

joelwiley
And you base this conclusion on......?
HunterTS4
I don't believe so.....why would you put a plane down in a field like that to make a video? He may have damaged the gear even in this landing. C'mon Chalet....you just sturing the pot on this one?

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

edgetl
After seeing your post I totally watched it in a different way. I'm nearly 50/50 on my judgement.

Fake:
1. The video lapses in between the instructor grabbing the yoke and the engine going out. Giving him time to lean the engine out without us seeing him do it.

2. Why isn't there audio? What was he saying to the kid?

Real:
1. If you "practicing" a dead stick why would you put an incompetent student at risk?

2. The prop clearly moves when the plane touches down leading me to believe that it would have struck the ground causing an expensive repair.

3. They way he approached that particular field (avoiding the pump house) doesn't seemed premeditated.
onceastudentpilot
same things I noticed
sunburneduck
There's no mixture control for the little Rotax engine on the J-170 if I remember correctly.
onceastudentpilot
I believe you are correct....that reddish-orange handle in there is the park brake.
onceastudentpilot
http://youtu.be/c1pMcLyB7vI
David7700
I don't think he's casually talking to his student. He was communicating with ATC and may have made a few remarks to the student to keep him calm, explain what he was doing, and remind him of what to do when they touched down and stopped.
shane55
I would say that the video is genuine.I had an engine failure while instructing a student in a PA-28 in march 2000. I talked through what I was doing to keep him and myself calm. Landed in a field with no damage.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

colinpayette
Are you capable of discussing your theory without putting others down? Really, there's no sense in that. Why are you so upset?
HunterTS4
I can. got a medical that says so anyways. Have a good weekend Chalet!

로그인

계정을 가지고 계십니까? 사용자 정의된 기능, 비행 경보 및 더 많은 정보를 위해 지금(무료) 등록하세요!
이 웹 사이트는 쿠키를 사용합니다. 이 웹 사이트를 사용하고 탐색함으로써 귀하는 이러한 쿠기 사용을 수락하는 것입니다.
종료
FlightAware 항공편 추적이 광고로 지원된다는 것을 알고 계셨습니까?
FlightAware.com의 광고를 허용하면 FlightAware를 무료로 유지할 수 있습니다. Flightaware에서는 훌륭한 경험을 제공할 수 있도록 관련성있고 방해되지 않는 광고를 유지하기 위해 열심히 노력하고 있습니다. FlightAware에서 간단히 광고를 허용 하거나 프리미엄 계정을 고려해 보십시오..
종료