Back to Squawk list
  • 34

Ajit Pai and Tom Wheeler agree: The FAA is behaving badly in battle against FCC

제출됨
 
Six former chairs of the Federal Communications Commission yesterday criticized the Federal Aviation Administration's fight against a new 5G rollout on spectrum that the FCC has studied and deemed safe to use. Republicans Ajit Pai and Michael Powell joined with Democrats Tom Wheeler, Mignon Clyburn, Julius Genachowski, and Michael Copps in writing a letter describing their concerns about how the FAA has tried to undermine public confidence in the FCC's decision-making process. (arstechnica.com) 기타...

Sort type: [Top] [Newest]


TimDyck
Tim Dyck 5
If there is any chance the 5G could create a safety concern to aviation then I expect the FAA to make sure all concerns are adressed.
FrankBarber
When the money changers are in the church then no one is safe.
skylab72
skylab72 3
Both agencies have functional and credibility issues. Many of them are legacy and many more related to more recent history. BUT, the real issues in this particular question are both technical and potentially life-threatening. They, therefore, need to be addressed by knowledgeable practitioners of the RF arts not the court of public opinion. As a veteran of both FAR battles and bandwidth wars, I have fairly high confidence a reasonable solution can be found, and a near certainty the optimum solution will not.
royhunte92
I'm still trying to figure out why the huge push for 5G, I can't figure it out!
denny9r
The "less interference and blazing speed" applies to the 20-30 GHz band requiring high density micro-cells that will initially appear only in high population areas. The build-out will take years to decades. So telecom convinced the FCC stop-gap 5G expansion is needed in lower bands providing only modest speed increases. Why? To be able to sell the excruciatingly expensive smart phones that are 5G capable. In order to "Grab" and auction the needed valuable spectrum FCC has been relocating other services at serious expense (both time and dollars) to those services. Hence the friction. While this is not a trivial national economic issue, the FCC has been tone-"hard-of-hearing" to safety concerns about their spectrum reallocation. Some FCC Leaders are likely destined for rewarding jobs in telecom and face no legal jeopardy for their decisions. So it only requires following the money.
dfromd
The last sentence says it all. The accuracy of NWS forecasts are also possibly jeopardized by 5G.
paultrubits
Online gambling.
TorstenHoff
Ironically, one is less interference.

5G has shorter reach, so the transmissions are more local, and devices will have to deal with less crosstalk.

The higher transmissions rates are also nice.
weecosse
weecosse 1
Me too. I just came back from a trip to rural Tennessee and had trouble getting two bars in my 4G phone.
manarii
Follow the money.
KXTD
Follow the money.
tsberry901
Sorry FCC, but I side with the FAA.
denny9r
Of Course former commissioners agree. Four of the last eight FCC Commissioners joined the same private equity firm on resigning. It is true that equipment designs that do not meet the requirements of prior authorizations are a serious piece of the potential problem here, but they were employed by aerospace in good faith. A little like finding out your bullet-proof vest isn't bulletproof but that doesn't make you feel safe.
avionik99
I guess the FAA thinks America's 5G is somehow different then that of other countries 5G? Idiots!! Just another junk science covid power struggle between the FAA and the FCC all the while ignoring the true science that it does not interfere!!
elnino54
elnino54 3
I don't get it - The FCC are responsible for controlling the radio spectrum and are aware of the frequencies in use by aircraft but seem dumbfounded that there is interference between aircraft and 5G that they have approved for use in America.

Either the FCC should not have allowed the 5G frequencies or given fair warning that there was interference between the two and informed FAA that aircraft using these frequencies will need to be updated to avoid the interference.

I don't see how FAA is at fault here.
w2bsa
w2bsa 4
The FAA is claiming interference when there is none. The FCC allocated the exact same frequencies as used in other parts of the world. There are no reports of interference anywhere else in the world.
denny9r
Also check the United Nations Agency ICAO; https://www.icao.int/safety/FSMP/MeetingDocs/FSMP%20WG11/IP/FSMP-WG11-IP08_ICAO%20Flight%20Operations%20Panel%20and%20IATA%20%20IFALPA%205G%20problem%20statement.pdf
It is not clear that arstechmica is apolitical or that its reporting may be assumed to be fact.
denny9r
There was no issue from Boeing's MCAS until there was
pcaronlpcaron
In the end the SWAMP will rule, money is first. How else do you explain politicians becoming multi-millionaires while in office? Nuf said.
bwfritzke
Sad when politics gets in the way of progress.
w1cavico
The question is Is it more important for Betty Sue to hear from Barbara Joe if Davy is going to ask her to the dance or should an airplane with a 100+ people on
board land safely ?
craiglgood
Craig Good -5
That is not the question at all. Not even close. There's no evidence that 5G is a danger to anything, and plenty of evidence that it isn't dangerous. Which you would know if you read the article.
w1cavico
The response is always "there's no evidence..."

Remember there is no evidence that Al Capone was anything other a legitimate business man who had tax issues.

P.S. back about 50 years ago I had a commercial First Class FCC Radio Operator's
License.

The FCC knows where its butter is and the FAA will cower and shift some of its cut and dried responsibilities to the pilots who will always be found responsible regardless.

Bill C.
manarii
Tax paying American citizens realize that the FCC is getting kickbacks from the sale of the spectrum. Wake up!
BayneJust
The FCC is getting kickbacks and lost track of their primary mission, regulating frequencies. Follow the money, 5G is not needed and it interferes with more than GPS frequencies.
phowry
This federal government agency "playground" feud, documents the obtuseness of the FAA. In light of this encounter, why did the media blindly legitimize the FAA's accusation of unilateral dereliction of duty by an aircraft manufacturer?

If you want to know what people think listen to what they say, if you want to understand their character observe their behavior.
craiglgood
The FAA is behaving as though someone there were an anti-5G conspiracy theorist. If there were an actual safety risk it would have appeared in those other countries by now.
GraemeSmith
Canadians have banned 5G towers near airports.

FAA has issued an AD regarding risk of interference to existing equipment and adjusting minimums and approaches that depend on equipment that might be affected.

No - there is no problem...........
Geldridge
I have no confidence in the FCC and haven't for years. We've done just fine without 5G so why would we need it now? The FCC has lost my vote of confidence ever since they started auctioning off frequencies AS IF THEY OWNED THEM. They have created such a crowded mess on the airwaves, destroying good sounding analog cell phones and replacing them with this horrible garble garble digital stuff and replacing perfectly viewable analog television with stuttering pixelated digital video signals. Give back my analog cell phone. Give back analog television. At least when signal might grow a little weak you could still view it. This is NOT progress and it's because of the FCC.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

curtcannon
Not sure why some people feel the need to grind their political axe on here. How about taking it elsewhere - there are plenty of places on the internet where you'll be welcomed with open arms.
WillyRoss
Bill Ross 18
Thanks for veering straight to the toilet and crafting the issue about culture. Stay on task
linbb
linbb 12
So you are really off target with this racist comments about people and faiths wow surprised if you dont get booted off of here. What you say is the same type of language being used to divide the country about race problems and also against religion in general. You are JJ the root of many problems in society these days.
TimDyck
Tim Dyck 3
If all your going to post is political hate crap why don’t you go on Facebook were that seems to be acceptable.

[This comment has been downvoted. Show anyway.]

curtcannon
An attempt for the FAA to regain some "safety" credibility after the Max fiasco.

로그인

계정을 가지고 계십니까? 사용자 정의된 기능, 비행 경보 및 더 많은 정보를 위해 지금(무료) 등록하세요!
이 웹 사이트는 쿠키를 사용합니다. 이 웹 사이트를 사용하고 탐색함으로써 귀하는 이러한 쿠기 사용을 수락하는 것입니다.
종료
FlightAware 항공편 추적이 광고로 지원된다는 것을 알고 계셨습니까?
FlightAware.com의 광고를 허용하면 FlightAware를 무료로 유지할 수 있습니다. Flightaware에서는 훌륭한 경험을 제공할 수 있도록 관련성있고 방해되지 않는 광고를 유지하기 위해 열심히 노력하고 있습니다. FlightAware에서 간단히 광고를 허용 하거나 프리미엄 계정을 고려해 보십시오..
종료